Me Burke, gf Jane, her bf Ernie
I have been seeing Jane since she was in an open marriage with her husband 3 years ago. She was always very open with him about the situation, told him every time we would see each other. But her husband always came first, and I was respectful and understanding of this. Fast forward to today 3 years later, she’s in the process of divorce with her husband (the divorce has nothing to do with me). She has been seeing Ernie for about a year.
Everything was going fine. She would see me the majority of the time, and see Ernie when she could. He lives further away so they’d try to plan to see each other when they could. I would see her on Saturdays or Sundays.
The problems arose when we would do things with the 3 of us. She would always put him first, and almost act like she was ashamed to be seen with me. Mind you, she didn’t act like this unless Ernie was around.
The biggest incident of this was when we saw Jane perform. I got to the entrance first and waited. Ernie came a little after me. When they opened the doors, people who showed up after me were going in, and I wanted to make sure we got in early so we could get the seats that Jane wanted us to get. So I went in front to get it and motioned to Ernie to come with me, but he didn’t. So I went in ahead. When I got to Jane, she didn’t even seem happy to see me as she usually does. But I understood she was nervous. Instead of greeting me in anyway, she just asks where Ernie is. I tell her that he’s right outside and will be in soon. She didn’t kiss me, I just kissed the side of her head. Then Ernie walks in, she goes up and kisses him instantly, in front of me. She doesn’t kiss me once during this whole event, she kisses him a few times. Days later, I mention this to her. She’s very apologetic and sad and surprised. She didn’t realize. But that’s the problem for me, she didn’t realize. Ever since things started getting serious with Ernie, she’s been constantly worried about losing him. I’m patient and by nature try to make sure people have to worry about things as little as possible, so I reassure her that it’s fine and I understand that she has to make him feel reassured. Ernie has a lot of anxiety about doing the wrong thing and messing things up with Jane.
Because of her constantly putting me second, I suggest she make him her primary. I didn’t do this because of her actions, but because her actions are clearly stemming from her caring and wanting him more than me. Since then, Jane has been communicating with me less and less. this has been hard for me, partly because I miss talking to her constantly, and partly because I’ve realized I have codependency issues that I’m working on now. And I acknowledge that I didn’t communicate my issues with her properly and made her feel bad, even though that wasn’t my intent.
I’ve tried to talk to her about these things, and she would shutdown and say she can’t talk about things. I think this is partly my fault for not being a good communicator. I really tried using the right words, but it seems I say the wrong thing and she stops talking. And I can understand her getting overwhelmed, so I say ok. I wait, and let her come to me when she is able to. Months, and she doesn’t come to me to talk about anything deep. And I can’t bring anything up because she’ll shut down and be upset at me if I try.
Recently, the 3 of us we were at a party together. She was clearly overwhelmed but no matter how many times I asked her if she was ok, she would tell me she’s fine. And then proceed to talk to Ernie about what is going on. Ernie suggested Jane and I sit next to each other on the couch for a while, and she wouldn’t lay with me. I lay there caressing her and she acted like she didn’t want me anywhere near her (she later said that’s not the case). Then after a while I asked if I should switch with Ernie to her, and she said “sure” (that exact word). I did, and she immediately cuddled with him. Again, it’s not so much the things that are going on, but that she won’t even communicate with me and I’m constantly left in the dark.
Now she’s been talking about having baby fever, and it seems she’s been talking to Ernie about a future and family with him. She’s had a procedure so she couldn’t accidentally get pregnant. She’s always said she doesn’t want to have babies. Ernie has been talking to her since before she’s wanted one, about how he wants children with her. And now, apparently she does. She says he’s made his intent clear, so she sees that future with him and not me. But I haven’t even had a chance to talk to her about these things. And since then, I’ve imagined what our daughter would look like. I mention this to Jane and she says she hasn’t put much thought into what our daughter would look like. She’s only been thinking about those things in terms of Ernie. She’s likely moving in with him at the end of the year.
I will note, she’s been constantly struggling with this. She didn’t want to communicate to me about her taking to Ernie about a baby and future because she was afraid I would get angry and breakup with her. Even though I’ve never been angry about her communicating anything with me. I’ve only been upset about the lack of communication. She’s struggling with trying to make sure everyone feels needed, but clearly she cares more about Ernie.
So she doesn’t see a future with me, even though she loves me and doesn’t want to let me go, and I love her more than anything. But also, she’s never put me first, and I don’t think it’s reasonable to think she ever will.
What should we do?