I (F22) and Crimson (T/T21) lived together with a third roommate (F22) in another house at the beginning of the year. In January Crimson came to us two and mentioned that they were going to apply to government housing, which would have left me and the third roommate in a bind where we could no longer afford the house we were staying in, therefore we ultimately decided to all three split ways at the end of our lease that ended on April 15th, 2026.
While the other two made their own plans to move, my boyfriend David (23M) and I decided that we liked the complex I live in so we applied to transfer units which would have pushed the entire houses move out date to March 24th. When this came to light Crimson came to us and told us that they were denied housing, had recently lost their job, and our third roommate could not accommodate to have them move with her, so my bf and I offered a spare room to Crimson on the basis that they pay us $350 a month in rent while they look for a more affordable place to live.
The houses I live in have a policy in their lease that says rent is due on the first of every month, late on the 5th ($150 late fee), and eviction on the 15th- no partial payments. Crimson over the last 6 months has routinely had their rent late for various reasons- some within their control and some not- and former roommate and I have had to cover for them a lot. My bf and I decided that in offering them a place to have them pay a fixed rate of $350USD. We feel as if this is fair because it is far below what a third of staying in the house would cost split evenly and it also provides space for them to save for their own place.
Crimson landed a job where they make considerably more money than they used to and has expressed to us that they have now started to look more sincerely for a place to move (stated to us last week on Monday 5/25/2026) in which we were excited for them. They came to us and said that they were looking at a 1B/1BA apartment running for $950USD plus a few utilities putting their monthly cost at around $1000USD monthly. While David and I silently glanced at each other as the previous month of May's $350 was not paid in full, we congratulated them on their findings and hoped they got approved.
Here is where things get tricky. I drive a 2003 Lincoln town car that looks like it is straight out of a hood classic and has recently died out on me (R.i.p toes you will be missed). Last Wednesday I was sitting in the car dealership looking at rates and such with my bf when we found a car exactly what I was looking for and for a pretty affordable price. Before I committed to the purchase, I texted Crimson to ask if they would have their rent on time and in full because that would determine if we could swing the downpayment or if we should wait another week if we were going to have to budget an extra $350 for rent this month (bf and I both get paid weekly on Fridays) in which Crimson responded with an enthusiastic yes to having it on time and in full. With their yes, I proudly drove home my new car without the worry of affordability.
Fast forward to two days later on Friday, Crimson comes to us and says that they are moving out before June 1st (Monday) and will not be paying rent at all for June because they used their rent money for a security deposit on their new findings and "figured we would be fine without it". With this being said, I was left in a panic because that means not only would we be stuck with finding the $350, but we would also have to find the $150 late fee plus most of the utilities are typically due the first week of the month.
My personal issue with this is that I specifically asked them if they would have their part of the rent on time and in full and was very transparent about why I was asking so if they had any doubt then I could plan for that. I feel like I have been very open and honest in communication with them about the situation. Any other month or even week we would have been able to accommodate this but with three days till bills are due to tell us you aren't going to be contributing puts us in a bit of a bind.
Attached is the text chain between Crimson and I within the last week about the situation. Included in this chain is them comparing our financial situations, telling us they are moving out, asking to stay until June 8th without paying rent, and generally finding any excuse to make it to where we shouldn't be charging them anything. This chain leads all the way up to present day (June 2nd) where they've sent me $75 and still arguing about how much they should have to pay.
\*\*extra info\*\*
These are things I don't think matter in the scenario but you might:
Crimsons new job makes (17/hr 35-40hrs/week)
David makes $27/hr 72 hrs/week
I make 8/hr 25-30hrs/week
Included in Crimson's rent comes a room, bathroom, kitchen (always stocked with essentials and snacks), pet fee, utilities, wifi, and in house laundry unit for the fixed rate of $350USD.
David and I believe the feeling of being "unwelcome" has derived from a mild interaction where we asked Crimson to please not have their guests stay at the house when they are not present. (I.E., having a guest stay in their bedroom while they leave for work for 6+ hours)
I am limited in my work schedule because I am a full time university student that also undo goes continuous treatment for cancer, so $350 is a lot for me to try and budget around.
David's brother came over one night and bought us Chinese takeout?
With this being said- AIO for demanding June rent and being upset about how i've been affected?