r/southafrica May 22 '25

Discussion Genocide?

There are claims that there is a genocide taking place in South Africa and I think the fact that the US is adamantly propagating this propagandistic narrative is more reason not to trust them.

Furthermore, I am disappointed in Trump's refusal to at least consider Ramaphosa's sentiments during yesterday's meeting. He seems to be both gullible and ignorant.

I should finally mention that I am deeply hurt by our fellow white South Africans who are proudly reinforcing these claims of genocide. I know that our country is run by an incompetent and self-serving government that seems to not have any concerns about economic development. However, seeing a cohort of white people take the stance of validating that there is a genocide is painful to witness.

As someone born post apartheid, I'm finally starting to see.

387 Upvotes

265 comments sorted by

View all comments

104

u/danievdm Western Cape May 22 '25

Whilst any murder is a very sad thing, the amount of white farmers murdered in a recent 12 month period is minute compared the broader context of murders generally - https://www.thesouthafrican.com/news/politics/fact-check-donald-trump-video-on-sa-farm-murders-contains-many-falsehoods/. It is deliberately being blown out of context.

38

u/LegitimateFoot3666 May 22 '25

More than that

Genocide is a political act

No political or racial motivation has been proven

3

u/OpenlyINFJ May 23 '25

What about Malema’s “kill the boer” gatherings and propaganda?

3

u/ZillesBotoxButtocks The price of liberty is convenience May 23 '25

What about them? No single murder of any white farmer or any white person has been tied - even remotely - to that chant.