I can not believe I actually spent my memorial day weekend watching this roller coaster of a show. What's most disappointing to me is the fact that the first season was so incredibly good. The characters were fleshed out and felt real. Their motivations were complex yet still believable. It didnt hold you hand and force feed you the theme. Then, the second season swooped in and took any of intrigue the first had built up, and ruined any semblance of cohesion.
I could tell immediately something was wrong when the romance plot between Caspian and Maddie took place. Maddie being 14 wasn't relevant to the story she could've easily been been 17 or 18 and the story wouldn't have changed. The introduction of Justine seemed to be the only call to this. Maddie wasn't able to drive due to her age, but that could've easily explained through her not having a car.
On that, the friendship between Maddie and Justine was what best grounded the first season for me. Their relationship was so human and well written. Instead of her being one of the connections that Maddie treasured, she was quite literally no where to be seen after the first couple of episodes. That's pretty normal in real life, but this is a show that has to actively introduce characters and relationships.
The pacing in this show was abysmal. In a show where the plot is not solely driven by the
interpersonal relationships, you can get away with skipping over a few things. This show, unfortunately, heavily relies on the relationships. That's literally THE maior theme. I can forgive shows like Steven Universe and The Owl House because they we cut short with little foresight. But, from what I've seen online, the creators knew exactly how much time they had to execute this story. This show was created with a distinct beginning and an end in mind but falls flat in its follow through.
Here are a couple of things that I just dont like:
● Cyclic universe only being explored for maybe 15 mins
● Complete 180 flip on the morality of the Uls
● Not exploring MIST as a character
● MIST falling in love with her creator
● Lack of effects on Caspian from being Trumaned
● Trying to downplay the implications of desecrating the Inca ruins
tldr: I enjoved watching a lot of the show and was dumbfounded by the awful ending.