r/Gilbert • u/Asleep-Surprise1360 • 8d ago

Roof replacement recommendations

Anyone have a recommendation for roof replacement? Have bids from Canyon State and AZ Shingle Pros. Numbers are almost identical but no clue as to which way to go. Thanks…

6 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

7

u/Super-Catch-609 7d ago edited 7d ago

When bids are basically identical, I’d look less at the number and more at who you trust to actually run a clean job. Things like communication, how detailed the scope is, warranty terms, and who’s actually doing the install (in-house crew vs subs) end up mattering way more than a small price difference. Ask both who your point of contact is once the job starts and how they handle decking issues if they find rot.

Also worth checking how specific their quotes are. If one breaks out underlayment, ventilation, flashing, and potential wood replacement more clearly, that’s usually a good sign they won’t surprise you later.

For what it’s worth, I’ve worked with eagle ridge pros in Utah on a roof quote before, and what stood out was how straightforward they were about scope and timelines. Even just that experience made it easier for me to compare other bids because I knew what questions to push on.

5

u/Sugar_Cane_320 8d ago

I used monsoon roofing back in Nov and it was a good experience

2

u/Serious__Basket 8d ago

Same, we used them and they were fantastic.

6

u/D-man-Realty 8d ago

I can’t hurt to get a couple more bids.

3

u/Ok-havingfun 8d ago edited 7d ago

Right Way Roofing. They use a really cool underlayment that’s basically lifetime. More expensive but worth it

2

u/mizz_muppet 8d ago

Arizona Roofing Solutions did our home in January and came in a bit lower than some of our other quotes. We were happy with the work.

2

u/IzzytheShepherd 8d ago

Advanced roofing, they have a better underlayment system then what you’re gonna find anywhere else there’s a fiber that doesn’t dry up and has a 30 year real warranty that includes labor as well as material.

2

u/JeveSt0bs 8d ago

Aspire did a good job at a fair price for me.

2

u/AZTerp1080 7d ago

We’ve gotten fair prices and good service from Renco Roofing.

2

u/CreativeStay1916 7d ago

Check out REAL Roofing. I just got bids from 5 companies and this was my top pick. Comparable pricing to others. Out of the 5 estimates, 2 came back identical.

1

u/chilipalmer99 8d ago

Power Peak Roofing here in Gilbert.

1

u/Sensitive_Access_959 8d ago

Call Brown roofing. They gave me the best price by a pretty wide margin and did great work. They also will be honest about fixing vs replacing, while most places will just tell you it needs replaced.

1

u/Level9TraumaCenter 8d ago

Eco Roofing Solutions did ours. No complaints, fast and efficient job.

1

u/CzechmateTSO 7d ago

I used German Roofing out of Mesa and they did a great job and very good communication along the way.

1

u/amb_weiss69 7d ago

Overson roofing

1

u/luckymountain 8d ago

We used State 48 Roofing after getting multiple quotes and couldn’t be happier.

1

u/azgli 8d ago

Mine was done by Mulcock Roofing. They have been very good to work with and happy to tell me what I can do on my own to maintain the roof and get the most life out of it. When I have requested quotes for repair work they have always been reasonable.