r/vexillology • u/Vexy Exclamation Point • Feb 01 '16

Discussion February Workshop: Symbolism

Previous Workshops

This topic was recommended by /u/MastaSchmitty, who won the January contest. The floor is open for discussion on how best to incorporate symbolism when designing a flag.

Specifically:

  • How do you distinguish flags with strong symbols from "logos on a bedsheet?"
  • How detailed should symbols generally be on flags?
  • What are some of your favorite examples of symbolism in flags?

Any other questions are welcome!

22 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/bakonydraco River Gee County • Antarctica (Smith) Feb 09 '16

I like symbols that are simple while being instantly recognizable. Symbols that are too simple to be unique lack emotional heft, and symbols that are overly-complicated are confusing. You want something that people can recall immediately and uniquely.

I like symbols that fit organically in a flag rather than feel like they are tacked on. It's okay to design a symbol first and then the flag around it, but it shouldn't feel like you made a logo, picked a background, and slapped them together. Proper use of color (balance, contrast, tincture) can help greatly with this, as can positioning and size.

2

u/i_have_an_account Australia Feb 10 '16

The balance between simplicity, recognisablity and complexity is definitely a big part of it. You are on to something there.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CPoON_qU8AAomfF.jpg

This flag would be instantly recognisable with no explanation of which country it is. Something similar used to appear on the money, appears in the national airline and on the locally made sticker for produce.

1

u/i_have_an_account Australia Feb 11 '16

I'm not too sure, but I think your point here is that there is more to it than the balance I mentioned above. I like the kangaroo symbol, looks good as a tag on an Australian made product, but it feels amateurish and un-flag-like. I would be pretty upset if this was seriously proposed as Australia's flag.

Is that what you are getting at?