r/roastmystartup 18h ago

Notice: Journaling app that surfaces patterns. Just launched. Roast everything.

0 Upvotes

Just launched Notice on iOS this week. 3 months solo build. Want the harsh feedback before I commit to a v1.1.0 roadmap.

What it is: a journaling app that surfaces one deep insights  per day about your own life. Patterns you'd never have spotted yourself. Stuff like "you sleep 40 minutes less on days you drink coffee after 2pm." You log moods, habits, and short reflections; the app does pattern detection locally and tells you what it found.

Decisions I made that might be roastable:

- Free to download. £4.99/month or £39.99/year for "Notice Plus" (unlocks the full insights feed and unlimited reflections).

- iOS only at launch. Android nowhere on the roadmap.

- Pattern detection is statistical methods, not LLMs. I genuinely don't think AI-generated insights are the right tool for journaling, but maybe I'm wrong.

App Store: https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/notice-journal-habits/id6769771645

What I want roasted, specifically: 

  1. The positioning. Is "the journal that pays attention" actually different enough from what's already in the App Store, or am I lying to myself? 

  2. The pricing. £4.99/month feels right to me. Other indies have told me it's too expensive for an indie launch with no reviews. Am I leaving money on the table or am I overpricing? 

  3. iOS-only. Half my potential audience is on Android. Am I being lazy or strategic? 

  4. The feed mechanic itself. Is "patterns surface into a feed over time" the right pacing, or do users want one big weekly summary or something denser? 

Tell me what's actually broken. I'd rather hear it now than learn it from declining numbers in 3 months. 

Background for context: 18, solo dev, no funding, no team. First app. Earning from indie work, no salary, so the cost of being wrong is real.


r/roastmystartup 15h ago

Roast my AI design tool — one sentence in, a full design system + screens out. Real product or toy?

3 Upvotes

The product: v-1.design. Type one sentence ("habit tracker for runners") and it generates a named design system — contrast-checked color palette, type scale, components — plus every main screen as real React/Tailwind you can copy. Then you point at any screen and say "redo this darker" and it redraws it. It's for devs/founders who can build the app but freeze when it's time to make it look good.

The market: crowded and a little scary. v0, Lovable, Bolt, and Figma's AI stuff all circle this space. Most of them spit out a one-off screen; my bet is on the design SYSTEM part — consistent tokens across every screen so the whole app stays on-brand, not just one pretty page.

Where I think I'm weak (be honest with me here): v0 has Vercel's whole distribution machine and I have about 40 followers and zero marketing budget. Vague prompts can still give you a generic-looking first pass. And honestly I'm not 100% sure the "design system" framing even matters to buyers vs. them just wanting "give me one nice screen."

Stage: it's live, payments actually work (one-time credit packs), I have a handful of users and basically $0 revenue. What I need is brutal feedback on whether the core promise is actually compelling or whether I'm solving a problem people don't really feel. Free to try, no card: https://v-1.design

Roast the positioning, the pricing, the demo, whatever you want — mostly I want to hear why you wouldn't pay for it.


r/roastmystartup 20h ago

Roasy My App - Gamification Budget App

3 Upvotes

Built a savings app where each goal is a mountain you climb (deposits = progress up the slope, with streaks to keep the habit going). The entire point is that it should NOT feel like a budgeting spreadsheet.

So the one thing I need before launch — from this screen alone, gut reaction:

A game you'd open daily, or a chore you'd ignore?

One word is fine. If it's "chore," tell me the thing that's pushing it that way.

Website