r/polyfamilies • u/pastasauce6463 • Apr 17 '26
How do poly families handle kids’ new friendships when you’re not out to other parents?
Hi all :) posting from a throwaway because this involves my family and I want to be respectful to everyone involved.
I’ve been practicing polyamory for 10+ years and am currently in a long-term polyamorous V structure. My nesting partner and I share a child (elementary age), and my meta and I are close friends. All relationships have been established for 5+ years. I’m also the primary parent and handle most of the day-to-day parenting, social coordination, playdates, etc.
We also have a regular weekly dinner where my meta is usually present, so inclusion in our home isn’t unusual; this situation just felt different because it involved new people we’re not out to.
In my own adult life, I don’t build close relationships with people I can’t be fully out to. It’s easier and more aligned for me. But my child isn’t me, and I don’t feel it’s fair to limit their friendships based on whether other families are aware of or comfortable with our relationship structure (and I don’t think it’s kiddo’s job to manage/ navigate that kind of complex dynamic with friends’ parents).
This is actually the first time my child has had independent friendships where we weren’t already friends with the parents first. My child wanted to invite a friend and their family over for dinner at our home, which we were happy to support.
We are not out as poly to this family and have only met the parents twice, but the kids play together often. That raised a question in our household about whether another partner should be included in that kind of setting, and if so, in what capacity (e.g., as a “friend” vs. openly as a partner).
There were a lot of valid considerations and feelings involved:
- Wanting to be inclusive and not make anyone feel excluded
- Wanting to respect privacy and avoid putting people in an awkward position when we’re not out
- Wanting to keep things simple and comfortable for a new social situation with other parents
- Wanting autonomy over hosting in our home
- And most importantly, wanting the evening to go well for our child
I sometimes feel tension between wanting autonomy in my own home/hosting and wanting to be inclusive of partners, and I’m trying to figure out what’s reasonable and sustainable long-term, especially as my child builds more independent friendships.
So my questions for other poly parents/families:
- Do you limit your child’s friendships to families you feel safe being “out” to, or do you navigate a mix?
- How do you handle events in your home when you’re not out to the other parents? Do you include all partners, some, or keep it more contained?
- Have you found ways to balance inclusivity for partners with the realities of your child’s social world (especially with newer or less familiar families)?
- How do you think about/ navigate situations where a partner may feel uncomfortable being present but not acknowledged as a partner?
I’m not looking to assign blame or anything, just trying to understand how others navigate this in real life.
The TLDR: How do you handle partner inclusion when your kid has new friends and you’re not out to their families?
Thanks in advance for any perspectives.
32
u/RAisMyWay Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
If you like them well enough, just have them over for dinner. We (my husband, metamour, and myself, who raised our daughter together in our home, with a platonic housemate) had people over sometimes, and sometimes our partner(s) were there. We introduced everyone by first name. It's not like anyone has a sign on their forehead saying "I'm sleeping with that person" hehehe.
PDA was never a public thing in our house, but if someone gave someone a peck or a hug, no one noticed. No one asked who slept where or who was partnered to whom. I later learned they had some misconceptions, such as that I was partnered with our housemate or that my metamour was my sister - but no one came out and asked until we were much closer friends, at which time it was fine to tell them. No one ever asked anything about our non-live in partners who came to dinner. I'm certain they were just seen as friends.
It's easier than you think - what's in our heads is much more complicated. And if and when they do find out, I think it's an important step in normalizing alternative family situations - they see we have dinner just as people do.
4
u/pastasauce6463 Apr 17 '26
This is helpful, thank you. I can see how that approach works, especially when everyone is comfortable keeping things more low-key, and have done this with my other partner’s family (not in this little V dynamic).
In our case, light PDA is pretty normal in our home, which usually isn’t an issue since we’re out with our friends and family. But in this situation, my kiddo isn’t wanting to introduce any relationship context into this friendship yet, which I want to respect.
At the same time, not everyone feels comfortable being present if their relationship can’t be acknowledged in some way, so I’m trying to figure out how people balance that, especially in newer social situations where we’re not out yet.
24
u/Choice-Strawberry392 Apr 17 '26
Now we're getting somewhere. "Being acknowledged" is directly at odds with maintaining a normative facade for kiddo's (possible) benefit.
Quite a while ago, I gave up on the "being acknowledged" front. It was explained to me through a queer lens, after having watched straight, mononormative people. If a married person introduces their spouse, the new contact suddenly has (or believes they have) insight into this person's sex life and romantic life. And this insight is presumed to be available. There's an entitlement here, "I should know who you see naked."
And now here we are, in queer relationships, flipping this script around as if announcing who we see naked is some sort of status play. "I want strangers to know that we sleep together, because that's part of how I feel valued."
Here's the thing: the whole idea is a performance. A straight, married couple might, in fact, loathe each other. They might sleep in separate rooms and haven't kissed in a decade. The new stranger doesn't know that. Announced status is different than actual status, and the actual status remains private.
In very queer households and families, strangers get names. That's it. No insight into who loves who, who met first, who has their name on the mortgage, who has a contract with whom, who sleeps where. Nothing. It's all private. When all the normative models go away, there's no shorthand for positions or roles, and actual status, as ever, remains private.
This doesn't actually help you. If someone wants this dinner party to be a coming-out announcement, and your kiddo would rather keep anything potentially awkward on the low-down, then you have a family conflict. You'll need to negotiate that based on your values. But seeing this normative presumptive-insight example helped me adjust my values and intentions. Maybe it'll help in your discussion.
5
u/RAisMyWay Apr 17 '26
Really brilliant comment and response. You put into words what I couldn't. Saving for future use.
8
u/RAisMyWay Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
As open and out as I generally am, in my opinion, kiddo's wishes win in this particular situation. Kiddo can't opt out of dinner. Once kiddo sees you respect their boundary, they may be more likely give more space later (and there will come a point when they are older that it won't just be up to them anymore).
Does partner feel they must be acknowledged as a romantic connection at this particular dinner with these new people? Maybe they prefer to sit this one out? It sounds like they do get acknowledged with others, so it's not like they're typically kept a secret (which I wouldn't like or do to anyone). If this new group dinner goes well, maybe later on that aspect can be discussed with kiddo, explaining how it feels to partner and suggesting a more open approach next time.
5
u/aeipathiies Apr 17 '26
Yes! The kids comfort should always take priority. Not our feelings. I am in a quad in a not queer friendly area. People who aren’t accepting or we don’t know well just get first names. They may find out who is legally married to whom but that’s as far as anything is said.
4
u/amymae Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
But in this situation, my kiddo isn’t wanting to introduce any relationship context into this friendship yet, which I want to respect.
Well there's your answer. Debate over IMO. If your partner gives you grief for respecting your child's very reasonable boundary, I would honestly consider distancing myself from that partner, possibly permanently. They are not ready to be in a partnership with someone who has kids growing up if they are going to put their feelings first instead of the kids'.
(ETA: If they easily agree to respect the kid's boundary and keep personal information private, but they then have feelings about that that they would like to separately and privately process with you later [not your kid], then that's a different story and totally valid. As long as they understand that just because they have crunchy feelings about it does not mean that there is anything wrong with the kid's request or that they or you should pressure the kid to do something differently. Just that sometimes feelings happen, and adults can deal with those feelings in adult ways without making it the kids' responsibility to manage their feelings. Just because they want to keep that information private, does not mean the child is ashamed of them, just that they are socially aware and prudent.)
3
u/amymae Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
At the same time, not everyone feels comfortable being present if their relationship can’t be acknowledged in some way,
Presumably the person in this scenario you are referring to is an adult. And they made adult decisions that they get to own, but the child does not have to own that adult's decisions. So the adult needs to put on their big boy pants and stop playing the SJW victim and let the child make decisions about how much or how little to share without getting offended about it. At the end of the day, it's not about you. It's about the child and their friendship and that's already tricky enough to navigate as a kid without adults making you feel guilty for how you do so. If an adult is too immature to recognize that this is not about them and their feelings, then they should not be in a polyamorous relationship with anyone where kids are involved. We have a responsibility to mitigate any potential negative consequences of our adult choices on our children, because they did not get a saying those choices so they do not deserve the consequences thereof, including potential social consequences, and sometimes that means being okay with keeping personal information private.
2
u/Choice-Strawberry392 Apr 17 '26
Thanks for saying this. I didn't want to read too much between the lines, but you're exactly right.
10
u/Quiet_Paradox95 Apr 17 '26
We're regularly taking part in activities at a nearby community center that's focused on families. For some time now my husband and his partner have organized a cooking group there which I participate in as well. Our kids and my metas kids are also present most of the time. And they have friends there too. But we've participated in other activities there as well. At some point there were some rumors about what our dynamic was. Some people were even gossiping and worried about whether I was cheated on by my husband. My husband and his partner ended up having a conversation with the boss of the community center and came up with a plan to even organize a talk that would focus on polyamory and our dynamic in particular. But in daily interactions we would just openly talk about it to people if they asked. We don't want to burden anyone with something that's not relevant to the context. The other day we were at a parent-baby group with our little one at the same community center. My husband was about to introduce himself as polyam in the introduction round, but the boss and I told him it wasn't relevant in this setting.
So I think it's really important to not over explain when people are not asking. Just try to be yourself in the moment. As long as your kiddo or any other people involved don't feel uncomfortable. So I would definitely talk to your nesting partner, your kid and your meta if I were you. Figure out a master plan together. I usually come out to new friends who are not in the community or parents of my kids later on when I feel a bit more comfortable with them.
I wish you the best of luck! 🤗
8
u/RAisMyWay Apr 17 '26
I think it's really important to not over explain when people are not asking.
So, so very important. We tend to think people are thinking or saying way more about us than they actually are - people are pretty wrapped up in their own lives. And, overexplaining doesn't help us normalize how....normal...it can be, so just being around us casually at first and seeing that we're pretty much regular human beings is a big step toward being comfortable enough to come out and ask about our family situation.
3
u/pastasauce6463 Apr 17 '26
Thank you! I appreciate the perspective around not over-explaining and letting things come up naturally over time.
In a lot of our day-to-day life, we’re pretty open in community spaces and events, so that approach has worked well for us in those contexts.
This situation feels a bit different because it’s in our home and involves a newer friendship. We’ve talked with our kid, and they aren’t wanting to introduce any relationship context here yet, which we want to respect.
I think where I’m getting stuck is how people navigate situations where one person isn’t comfortable being present without their relationship being acknowledged, while at the same time it’s not a context where disclosing feels appropriate. I’m trying to figure out how others balance that in practice.
I think part of what I’m struggling with is that we’ve been out for so long that navigating when it’s not the right context to share feels new, and I’m trying to keep things ethical and fair for everyone.
2
u/sexloveandcheese Apr 17 '26
Do they feel uncomfortable making other plans for that night? I think there's no question that you have to respect your child's wishes. So the question becomes more about managing the emotions, and for your meta, deciding whether they'd prefer to come to dinner and not disclose the relationship, or prefer to skip this one.
2
u/amymae Apr 17 '26
This. If they cannot respect that it is the child's decision whether to keep that information private or not, then they do not get to meet this child's friend or their family. Full stop.
8
u/vrimj Apr 17 '26
Our metamours are both Auntie FirstName to the kiddo and we don't bother to explain beyond that usually but being a two mom family gives us a little more flexibility here I think.
6
u/amymae Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
I let the kids decide how much or how little to share. I do not ask them to lie.
I explain to them that sometimes some information is private (even though it's not a secret), that they do not owe other people personal information and that it's okay to hide things that they want to keep private if they decide to, but that it is their choice. That I will back them up and be proud of them and not be offended no matter what they decide. Some people don't deserve your truth. And that will naturally limit how close and vulnerable you are able to become with them, but that still doesn't mean you owe that to them. And it's also fine to take your time to figure out which category that person belongs in until you know them better. This is especially important that the child not feel pressured to disclose or not disclose either way, if nothing else, as a safety issue.
For little kids, I just let them say whatever they're going to say, and I field any follow-up questions appropriately. Sometimes, if I read the room as more conservative, I will say we are a blended family (technically true), and that's typically well received. I also often say, "Yeah, we're all co-parenting together. Always outnumber them! Lol." And I keep the big scary P word out of it unless they ask directly.
4
u/abitofaclosetalker Apr 19 '26
Speaking as a child raised by evangelicals- Limiting/restricting your kids’ friendships because of your own adult beliefs/choices is not the answer.
There’s nothing abnormal about a household with more than 2 “parent-aged” adults at the dinner table/with bedroom.
Your kids almost certainly already have friends who have grandparents, aunts/uncles, family friends, stepparents, other partners, and/or some guy named Jim who needs a place to crash living with them.
Unless you all make a regular habit of sexual activity at the dinner table, there’s no reason guests to your home would be pinged that your partners are anything different than the above-listed scenarios.
2
2
u/Temporary-Car7981 Apr 17 '26
I think your kid wants to be safe and wants all of the adults in the household to be present when his friend and family come over. Having one member of the family absent will be felt, and it's possible your kid already has said positive things about all partners. I agree with the introducing of each person by their first name, and it might be worthwhile to indicate the non-married partners last name so that the other child knows how to address them. I'm not sure if kids these days still say Mr or Ms but that's how I would want to be treated as an adult by a child.
2
u/NopeMoat Apr 19 '26
If your meta is usually over for dinner once a week, it seems like maybe the easiest would be to schedule dinner with this family on a different night of the week?
Is meta having feelings about possibly not being included?
Is there reason to think this family would be hostile to your lives? (Not that this changes anything about respecting your child's request to not tell them, just that for me personally I'd approach it differently if it was a probably fine if they find out eventually vs they might be hostile and nasty about it and now they know where I live)
Beyond this particular event, how old is your child and are you talking to them about how they feel about your relationships? This seems like possibly a sign that they're feeling some shame or fear of judgement, and its better to get that out in the open so they don't suffer alone with their feelings.
Come to polyam parenting 🙂 free group, lots of folks who've dealt with similar experiences juggling everyone's comfort levels. https://www.jengerardy.com/polyamparenting
38
u/Ecstatic-Chair Apr 17 '26
I have never discussed my relationships with the parents of my children's friends. When I lived with my kids' father and his girlfriend, we just called her by her name.
I think you want to discuss with your partners how they feel about it, and maybe your kid, too, but ultimately your love life isn't really relevant to your kid's friendships.