r/nakedandafraid • u/escapetheplate • 1d ago
Question Worst contestant of all time?
I’m gonna say Bill from season 18 episode 4.
He was absolutely useless as a teammate and creepy/rude asf. He was dismissive, selfish, lazy, and apparently had an insatiable thirst. All he talked about was water. When he had his teammate going back and forth (a 45 minute trek) to the old campsite for water and tells her that she would have to make a second trip for more water after he drank his share AND hers, I had to turn off the episode and take a break from it bc I was so angry.
Second place goes to the girl who brought a magnifying glass as her item (can’t remember what season).
49
u/SpackleButt 1d ago
Honora and her magnifying glass.
40
u/kornybizkit 1d ago
Honora hands down. Then they let her back and she threw all the knives into the river. Rotten to the core
17
u/catanddog5 1d ago
Also that time where she threw her teammates stuff in the water on an xl challenge.
1
u/Nate_C_of_2003 12h ago
She sucks but Chris wasn’t exactly nice to her in that challenge. He acted like an overprotective dad saying he didn’t want to see her get hurt but I’m pretty sure he really just didn’t want to care for more than one person. She’s capable of making her own decisions and if she got hurt falling off that fruit tree, so be it. HE wouldn’t have been harmed either way, so he should’ve just kept his mouth shut.
And then he had the NERVE to spit out the fruit—the fruit that SHE CAUGHT HERSELF—right in front of her face. If that doesn’t scream “disrespect,” IDK what does.
I would feel way more sympathetic for Chris if Honora told him to climb that tree and get the fruit, but she didn’t, so he shouldn’t have been upset with her.
This doesn’t excuse her throwing all his shit in the water by any means—that was definitely out of line—but Chris shouldn’t have been an asshole.
2
u/catanddog5 12h ago
Chris was definitely an asshole and wouldn’t want him as a partner either but honora was also a terrible partner in her Brazil challenge as well and that guy didn’t even do anything to her either.
In the end, she is responsible for her own actions.
11
u/oflowz 1d ago
Definitely the worst. She’s an overall shitty person not sure how they even let her on the show in the first place let alone a second time
8
u/Nice-Pomegranate2915 1d ago
Honora is beyond doubt the worst contestant ever . Three appearances on Naked and Afraid . Each time she's more inept and entitled than before . I believe she was recruited and employed by the producers because she was "drama " ! Then during the 10 episodes she was on Naked and Afraid XL she was even worse . She deliberately sabotaged her teammates by trying to destroy their equipment in a river . Yet the producers didn't pull her out of the competition instead they allowed her to stay until she tapped out because she was exiled by the other contestants because of her behaviour and she was too chicken to try to survive on her own .
3
u/TheWeirdIntern 22h ago
Three appearances? She was only on that Brazil one and for a few days on XL 1. Where are you getting 3 appearances and 10 episodes of XL? I think you might be combining her with someone else.
1
u/AdmiralAdama99 10h ago
Villains are great for reality show ratings. I'm sure she had no trouble getting invited back.
16
u/just_ge0ff 1d ago
Don’t forget that Hispanic guy that was asked to leave because he said something like “he was having terrible thoughts” or something like that. He freaked his parter tf out and the removed his weird ass!
There was another episode slightly more recent when a woman ended up with two male partners and one was INSANELY CLINGLY (and kind of reminded me of my first example above) towards the woman. His female and male partners were hugging over something and then you hear this pathetic “huh, huh, huh….” And they look over and dude there crying! So freaking cringy!
Sorry, I suck with names!
3
u/PlsContinueMrBrooder 1d ago
I was just thinking about the clingy guy and how he crumbled so quickly once there was another guy around.
1
u/TheWeirdIntern 22h ago
I think that was Daniel. Teamed with a dude from Canada and a thin woman from Vermont or New Hampshire.
13
u/Kenzi_Slays 1d ago
sam (goldstar lesbian chick) was the worst she was evil to her partner. she belittled him so badly my jaw dropped.
3
u/Randomperson143 1d ago
This is the one that always comes to mind she was literally so mean it came off as sociopathic
29
u/Cautious-Body-9748 1d ago edited 1d ago
Or the male contestant who, in an episode in a tropical jungle came prepared with duct tape only. He also decided to go cold turkey from smoking during the challenge. I think he lasted a couple days before severe withdrawal symptoms kicked in. Season 3 episode 8 in Nicaragua.
6
0
u/catanddog5 1d ago
He was also on the cl season in Africa where they could vote to banish someone from the bolma and he was the only one that didn’t self exile in the entire season.
14
u/Powerpoint629 1d ago
The lady who pooped in their water supply. Horrendous.
2
3
u/Queasy_Following1279 1d ago
I mean that was so stupid....BUT from memory, she wasnt bad apart from that stupidity. I could be wrong though because it was a long while ago i watched it.
6
10
u/Equivalent_Lab_8610 1d ago
For me it's between the guy who scraped up his junk on the tree after being a menace to his partner. Or the chick that was so mean to Joe.
Heathers 21 days were brutal to watch too, she was so mean to her partner.
4
u/BlueCX17 1d ago
Sam and that guy who is so incredibly toxic she likes split camps like two days in.
3
7
u/fq1234 1d ago
It’s a tie between honora and that “di-luted” chick.
2
2
1
u/Sweet_Information_76 1d ago
Think her name was carrie. Episode (I think) heart of darkness Honora was not stable.
7
u/18RowdyBoy 1d ago
Kate 😂😂
9
2
u/Kenzi_Slays 1d ago
idk y she kept going back, she had no mental strength, shed freak out at the slightest bit of discomfort.
2
u/Queasy_Following1279 1d ago
Cant believe how many chances she was given and wasted. I would give my left arm to be on the show and she threw 3 chances away.
2
u/Sweet_Information_76 1d ago
1, alana and dani.. The vegetarian. 2. Heather. She seemed to improve somewhat. Until I listened to her on steven's podcast. 3.bad nathan ties with seth
2
u/Nate_C_of_2003 12h ago
Not sure I’d say the worst but I really don’t like Russell. In every challenge I’ve seen with him, he was always so condescending and had a serious leadership complex.
2
2
u/Potential_Bread7203 1d ago
who was the girl who told her partner (swedish guy) that she was gonna kill him and then threw all of his wood in the water after dousing his fire?? she’s high up there for me.
1
1
u/FrenchiePirate 4h ago
Trish ... What a garbage human being... The way she went after Amber, acted like an ass and then even when the show was over she persisted in making videos threatening to kick her A$$ ... She's total trash
1
u/mggirard13 1d ago
There's honestly no way to answer this without further qualifiers.
For example, there are many contestants that have tapped on day one or day two. They are objectively bad at primitive survival and lack the mental toughness to even make it more than a couple days.
But then, they don't last long enough to show they are truly toxic, and can bring others down around them, or have mental instability, or can't light a fire or find water or hunt/gather.
Like I know Seth is really bad, but he outlasted, say, Karra who was partnered with Gary on S09E04 and tapped on day 3, or different Gary on S05E01 who tapped out on the first night due to cold.
1
u/DryWrap2532 11h ago
I just don't like Jeff, stealing others stuff and now he's back on the global showdown, but they did put a stop him from stealing others stuff this time. I don't know why they have him back.
44
u/Semi_Colon01 1d ago
Seth