I'll clarify that I'm coming to this show on the tail of The West Wing -- honestly, if I knew nothing about this show going into it, I'd probably have no complaints as it's entertaining enough; but following TWW (and with an 8.6 IDMB rating) I was definitely expecting more.
I'm towards the end of season 2, and the thing that tipped me over the edge into making this post was their "$1500/hr attorney" describing themselves as "liquid sex" on her way to a party. The contrast between the interviews with her and Oliver Babish from TWW is so stark it's amazing these are produced by the same person.
This illustrates a running complaint I have, that this show is like watching a show about serious adults written by horny teenagers. I appreciate a romance arc, but the whole will-they-won't-they story is literally the most overused relationship trope in tv. It's been so clear from the first episode who is going to end up with who, but they are obviously going to drag it out until the last episode. Plus every woman in the show is written as one dimensionally teetering on the edge of a freakout nearly every episode.
Again, don't get me wrong, the show isn't terrible, but I don't see how it has an 8.6 on IMDB.