r/TheOrville 5d ago

Question About Season 1 episode 2 Spoiler

Why didn’t the admiral let the ship go to Calivon space when they had Isaac?

We learn that the Calivon respect Kaylons so surely it should have been alright to go into their territory if they pretended Isaac was the captain.

19 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

11

u/UncontrolableUrge Engineering 5d ago

There is a standing order not to go there. If they had failed and antagonized the Calivon then the Union would have to face them.

10

u/ImStevan An ideal opportunity to study human behavior 4d ago

now imagine if calivon had the idea of having an entire union ship as a walk in interactive zoo exhibit

8

u/SadisticNecromancer 5d ago

“The Kaylon can go everyone else has to stay” that would probably be the in show logic. In real world logic the episode needs to happen and plot holes are all over every piece of media.

2

u/MGNConflict 4d ago

They'd almost certainly lose, too. You don't stick your hand in a wasps nest just because you dropped something in there, the blowback would be worse.

1

u/starbase63 2d ago

“Command Performance”

1

u/Dinoclawre 8h ago

Well that is what they did in the end no?

1

u/InfernalClockwork3 8h ago

The admiral did not let them though

-2

u/DipperJC 4d ago

This is what that question sounds like to me:

"Why doesn't Reddit let people post racial slurs on subreddits where people don't mind that?

We know there are racists who use Reddit, surely it'll be alright if they just keep it in their corner and it doesn't leak out."

The answer should be obvious - because the risks for catastrophe are simply too great, no matter how logical the argument may seem on its face.

3

u/Ralph--Hinkley Now entering gloryhole 4d ago

Whut?