r/KamalaKhan • u/AcceptableWheel • 6d ago

Comic Spoilers Did Kamala's views on Sinister change or is this just lazy writing?

Gallery image

Gallery image

28 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

18

u/BatgirlAndSpoiler 6d ago

I don't see anything contridictory between the panels. Kamala always has believed in redemption and being as moral as possible.

6

u/AcceptableWheel 6d ago

Good point. Question is is this a fake redemption or not.

9

u/KevinCow 6d ago

Kamala believes in the sanctity of life.

Page 1, the debate is about sacrificing some people to save other people. Kamala's against that.

Page 2, she's stopping X-Force from killing Sinister, and letting Sinister bring some people back to life. Even though Sinister is a villain, even though the people in question were bigots, Kamala still believes they deserve life.

7

u/Sovereignofthemist 6d ago

Don't see any issue here. Sinister or not if there's an opportunity here to truly help people and bring about positive effect she will carefully consider it. Which she does in Inglorious.

3

u/AcisConsepavole ⚡️🍕 Unciemuni! 6d ago

She just doesn't want to use his work to advance the Inhumans, originally. If memory serves, she's very anti-murdering Sinister then too.

Here, she isn't saying they should let him work, but there is a bit of a naïve "maybe he'll find a better way". This attribute of Kamala's is too often used for established Nazis and extreme cases and not genuinely morally gray individuals or even just good people who could use her help often enough. She has great foils in Qarin and Dr. Nikita Gaia, but they aren't used. Sinister is already being recycled for a Kamala plot?

2

u/KamenAttackRide 6d ago

Kamala has the mindset of a Spider-Man, Superman and Batman as in that she is anti-killing or never ending a life hero. A strong belief in that everyone deserves a chance at redemption and for a better tomorrow for everyone.

Even though 99% of Batman believes that the Joker is irredeemable and would never seek it but he will never fully close off that 1% chance he may seek redemption, so then he will try to help him achieve it If that 1% becomes a reality.

2

u/Kamala_Husband 6d ago

Off topic... Is she holding them up with her powers like telekinesis?

2

u/ravenwing263 6d ago

Why does Ahura hd have a tie

2

u/AcceptableWheel 6d ago

He was a CEO during the Nuhuman era. There was another lost tribe that was basically the mafia, they got Ahura in charge and he reorganized the whole culture into a corporation.

2

u/ravenwing263 6d ago

Teenage mob CEO is VERY funny

2

u/r2radd2 6d ago

I mean in the latter page she's advocating for X-Force not to kill Sinister. That's got nothing to do with her opinion on the guy, I think she just the type of hero that doesn't like killing.

1

u/Trick_Afternoon_7513 5d ago

Kamala has Batman anti killing rule. She doesn’t like nor will she ever kill so it isn’t contradictory