r/AmericanHorrorStory • u/Ambitious_Yak_3300 • 1d ago

Doing a rewatch

So I'm doing a rewatch, namely primarily the first season as I'm introducing it to a friend and I'm wondering what seasons you all would recommend. I recall not being that impressed with season 2, enjoying 3 and 4 and then somewhere around there they all sort of started to mingle together. And decrease in quality for me. Was there a season that stood out to you or a a few you might enjoy more than others. The first season stood out to me because it was the first season and it was so f***ked up and none of us knew what the hell was going on and we were introduced to my love, Evan Peters.

11 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

5

u/burner_acc9283 1d ago

Sorry Evan Peters cant be all our loves. We might have to fight to the death 😔

2

u/lookingpl 22h ago

omg I ran into him and his GF over in greenpoint last summer, completely unassuming, full beard super messy mop top, it was his nose that gave him away, what a beauty lol. otherwise looked like any random BK hipster just hanging

1

u/Ambitious_Yak_3300 11h ago

That is awesome! I love seeing celebs in the wild. Was he kind?

1

u/Ambitious_Yak_3300 1d ago

Hahaha absolutely we can share him!!

4

u/Krisgauj 1d ago

If you're an Evan Peters fan, then Cult is a must.

4

u/foiegraslover 1d ago

A lot of people consider season 2, Asylum, the best. You should let your friend watch them in order.

1

u/Muscle_Dude91 7h ago

When it comes to actual horror and what the show represents, I vote Asylum as the best one. Overall, my favorite is Coven.

3

u/lookingpl 22h ago

seasons 1 thru 3. done

2

u/CatLoliUwu 12h ago

freak show, death valley, and delicate weren’t great imo.

I think coven is the best season and its how I started

1

u/Muscle_Dude91 7h ago

Freakshow was not for everyone as it is a bit disturbing and makes you feel uncomfortable because of the characters, but I consider it one of the best seasons as that is how a viewer should feel when watching the season. Dandy Mott is one of the best characters in the entire series. Also, the ending is beautifully done and one of the few good endings from the show.

1

u/Material_Ad6743 3h ago

Roanoke (season 6) is worth the rewatch imo