r/EthicalNonMonogamy • u/Comfortable_Oil_4691 • 1h ago
Personal story Mono girl thrown into a love triangle
Hi, everyone. I was recently thrown in quite of an uncomfortable situation and I’d like some help to elucidate my doubts. Thank you so much in advance, I know it’s long…
Summing things up: I (26F) met G (34F) at a destination wedding, we hit it off and hooked up. Once I came back home, I kept talking very casually with G but I had no further plans because I don’t do long distance. After a week she started talking about coming to visit (because of a specific show) and I thought it would be fun to have her here, so I said I’d be down to see her.
She came after another week and, once we met, that’s when she told me she was non-mono.
I was a bit taken aback but, at first, I thought it could be a cool thing since I actually really liked her but we couldn’t move forward anyway due to the distance. So now there was a real compatibility issue.
Being brief, the week we spent together was me dealing with two situations: A very intense affair that culminated on her telling me she loved me, that she never saw herself going back to monogamy but for me… Well, you get it. And, on the other hand, her explaining to me her ex-girlfriend/“current who knows but I’m keeping the door open” dynamic.
When she was declaring herself to me she said I didn’t have to worry about this woman (let’s call her B). I understand now that I was loved bombed and that we were making very crazy plans (“let’s get to know each other calmly, you live your life, I live mine but let’s also aim for a future together”. Fucking crazy. On both parts. I see it now).
So I asked her if she was willing to “close the door” with B so we could at least start off with some chance. As a mono person, having known so many details of the relationship (why B broke things off with G, how their lives are completely enmeshed, how recent things were) I thought that leaving the door open for romance (I don’t mean cutting the lady out of her life) would just mean they’d get back together and, for so, it would cause me pointless heartbreak.
Again, I see now how bonkers the situation is. On my part as well. I understand I didn’t know and wasn’t willing to start dating G right away anyway but I hope you can understand how hard to grasp the whole ordeal was. I mean, I never explored non-mono and there were so many elements being thrown at me at once. I started reading “all about love” and I was mostly just listening and absorbing things as they came.
Anyways, she said no right away and that’s when I started to detach myself because of our incompatibility. I also believe she was unfair to me, she didn’t have to tell me about being non-mono at the wedding but, fuck, if you’re going to make the bold move of traveling half the country to see someone, maybe you could have told me in the 2 weeks we were talking?
And maybe don’t create the possibility of being mono if you’re still waiting for things to work out with your ex? Im not judging the lifestyle at all, please understand. I just feel badly treated by being included in such a situation.
I “broke things off” (sounds ridiculous to write that) because, once I had time and space to think, I just saw how things developed in a bizarre way. I’m not even saying that I wouldn’t be open to trying non-mono one day, but not like this.
And on that note, those are my questions… I realized G is not in a good place, and I found a lot of what she said beautiful in theory but not really sound once I observed her reality. I don’t attribute that to non-mono philosophy, I just think she is a bit lost with her life in general. So I was wondering how other people navigate those dynamics:
“The relationship I have with you has nothing to do with the one I have with her.”
Doesn’t make sense to me because our environments affect each other regardless… And I saw that happening in real time: She told me about why B broke things off with her… It was a deeply personal reason and, once i thought more about it, I questioned if I should have known at all. On the other hand, B found the book I gave to G and read an intimate and vulnerable message I wrote on it. Fuck, I’m sorry? What? That was my breaking point to be honest. That created a reaction in B that culminated on her talking about “getting back together” but she “just has to be more sure”. How come one thing does not interfere with the other? We are humans. I felt quite used, because of course G got some satisfaction out of it, if she is still seeking the affection of this lady. It feels nice to have someone “coming back” to you even if the reasons are… warped.
“Love is wild and we can’t chain it.”
Yes, I agree in so many ways but in this situation I just saw a lady who broke things off with another, one is chained to the possibility of coming back together (while trying to keep me at bay). G also told me that, once they were broken off and she started seeing other people, B started to go back on being interested in her. I don’t think that’s non-mono free love, I think that’s control.
“There is no hierarchy.”
But if your resources (both physical and emotional resources) are limited how come we can be equitable in sharing them. Someone will occupy more of your time and thoughts. Am I being too general? Let me be blunt on how I saw it: B broke things off with her but wants her close. Good for being an affection, convenient, but not good enough to be her girlfriend because “B doesn’t see a future with a person like G” (ouch, but not my problem, I don’t want to say the reason they broke up but it’s based on identity). I mean… to the bench you went? Am I too simplistic?
On the other hand, G involves me in this and expects me to wait while she figures out her life (translation: see if things will change with G) so she can give me answers. I felt like a second choice, the bench of the bench. I told her that and she said that it’s not about hierarchy but, with the practical situation in front of me, I truly don’t get it.
I’ve blocked her, the way things were conducted were too reckless and unkind to me. But I am reading and enjoying the book she recommended, I’ll get to the ethical slut as well. Again, I don’t attribute any of her poor behavior to her being non-mono and I wanted to know how kind people see those challenges. I don’t know what is the number one rule but I told her my opinion on it: Don’t include mono people on it unless they’re happy to try it. Fuck her.