r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Nov 29 '25

Episode Fumetsu no Anata e Season 3 • To Your Eternity Season 3 - Episode 9 discussion

Fumetsu no Anata e Season 3, episode 9

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.

Streams

Show information

All discussions

Episode Link Episode Link
1 Link 14 Link
2 Link 15 Link
3 Link 16 Link
4 Link 17 Link
5 Link 18 Link
6 Link 19 Link
7 Link 20 Link
8 Link 21 Link
9 Link 22 Link
10 Link
11 Link
12 Link
13 Link

We are currently trialing the default comment sort being temporarily set to random.

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

388 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

240 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/redJackal222 Nov 30 '25

March's parents didn't have a choice and they likely died when Parona convinced everyone to rebel against the Yanome.

And I don't think the man in black reincarnated as pre existing person. He most likely created his human form

1

u/Imaginary-End-08 Dec 03 '25

Right, evidence by the fact that he doesn't have parents.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '25

ijs that same evidence is "evidence" (i.e. the 'absence of evidence') of MiB being reincarnated into a human boy that tried to unalive themself (bc they were a 'she/they' not a 'he/him' for example) many such cases and MiB would literally be able to pick from the pack of kiddos

1

u/Imaginary-End-08 Dec 07 '25

Not sure I understand you. Are you saying that you don't think what I said was evidence? If so, then I'd like to add that someone would have contacted his parents.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25

The point I was making is that you saying "the boyform of MiB doesn't have parents" was evidence is actually an example of the 'absence of evidence'. The show doesn't mention MiB's parents, that doesn't mean they don't exist. But using the 'absence of evidence' as actual evidence is a logical fallacy.

2

u/Imaginary-End-08 Dec 09 '25

Ahh that makes perfect sense.

2

u/redJackal222 Dec 13 '25

It's still exteremly unlikely he didn't just create his body. We already know he has the ability to do that and the previous season even mentioned he created humanity. The most obvious and likely explaination is that he simply jsut decided he wanted to be a human and created a body for himself. Frankly the black one stealing a human body is completely unnecessary. The nokkers have a specficic goal in mind when they steal people's bodys that the black one doesnt share

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '25

Fushi has never just 'created a body' ever. He's only ever taken over bodys and reproduced objects that have physically existed that he's interacted with at least once. I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that MiB has different powers. He doesn't. He has the same powers as Fushi and always has. Fushi was basically MiB's eyes and ears in the world to learn about humanity.

Saying that he always had the power to just create life out of nothing where there wasn't life before is a bold claim to make, please provide me the episode numbers in this series where MiB does this even ONCE.

2

u/Thesunhawkking Jan 06 '26

I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that MiB has different powers. He doesn't. He has the same powers as Fushi and always has.

Uh what? Are we even watching the same anime here? When has Mib Ever demonstrated he has Fushi's powers? And he's constantly doing stuff Fushi can't do

1

u/redJackal222 Dec 14 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Fushi has never just 'created a body' ever.

I said the black one most likely created hs current body that he's using instead of taking over a pre existing body like the nokkers did because that's what you said. That the black one is taking over a pre existing person who passed on rather than him making a body for himself which is something we've already know he can do.

I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that MiB has different powers. He doesn't. He has the same powers as Fushi and always has.

You need to rewatch the series. The black one does not have the same powers as fushi. We even see earlier in this season taht he stops time temporarly when whats her name's brother is about to get hit by a car. Second, the previous season ALREADY TOLD US THE BLACK ONE CREATED HUMANITY.

That's not speculation. It's in season 2 episode 8 we're told this by the nokkers who said that the black one created humanity from the nokkers. The nokkers consider this existance to be a prison and think that everyone would be happier in paradise.

Fushi was basically MiB's eyes and ears in the world to learn about humanity.

This is wrong too. As I said last season we're told by the black one himself that his reason for creating Fushi was to be his replacement. It has nothing to do with him being MiB's eyes and ears. He wants Fushi to replace him but wants him to learn about humanity and learn about the world first.

MiB even says he had the ability to kill all the Nokkers if he wanted too but that he's not because he's using it as a chance for Fushi to grow. But that he can't do that in season 3 anymore because he gave away some of his powers to fushi and is losing the rest of them.

Season 2 episode 14

I'm not sure where you're getting the idea that MiB has different powers

I'm not really sure how you became under the impression that the black one only has the same abilities fushi does when we see him do multiple things fushi can't do throughout all 3 seasons. MiB is essentially this universe's God.

please provide me the episode numbers in this series where MiB does this even ONCE.

Like I said dude you really need to rewatch the series. I see tons of people in the comments making mistakes who seem to have forgotten details from the other seasons. I rewatched season 1 and 2 before starting season 3 and it really helped.

But the black one creates like twice in the series. First he creates fushi then he creates a body for piaron . And as I said earlier in season 2 episode 8 it's revealed that the black one actually created humanity itself.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

Bro, you quoted the Nokkers giving Fushi that info, so basically you believe the Nokkers in being truthful about MiB creating the universe. If I believed that at the time, I would've been more alarmed when he showed up in S3 acting like he had no more powers. Because that wouldn't have made much sense if he could always just 'snap his fingers' and disappear all the Nokkers at anytime he wanted.

He most likely did want Fushi to replace him, that's why he gave Fushi the capacity for all of his own powers. Fushi can't do things MiB can't also do, and MiB has taught Fushi the things he needs to be his own replacement. I also remember that from the series without doing a rewatch.

But you seem to think just because you got 2nd-hand info from characters, potentially even lies from MiB himself about his own powers (without ever ONCE demonstrating it-- i.e. he can create life anytime he wants but you yourself say he does it one time ever and FUSHI DOESN'T COUNT lol--

Fushi is literally a copy of MiB that needs to be filled with info because he's a blank slate. Again that is why Fushi and MiB have the same powers but lol don't mind me I just watched the same series you did to come up with that conclusion. He creates a body for pairon (that's your other example) I don't even have to look back at this episode to know that Fushi has that same power. He literally just created a new body for Mimori in this very episode!! Mimori's actual body was burned by the Nokker hunter, so yes Fushi creates new life out of thin air as much as MiB did, which is to say it's a 'copy' of what was there, in in the pairon body's case a copy of another person who was there.

In closing, don't take what other people say in discussion forums so personally some of us enjoy theorycrafting and it's hella joyless to have to read these itemized replies from someone who's obviously got a lot of time and toxic energy to argue with someone about a cool theory they had the positive enough energy to want to share on a reddit sub

1

u/redJackal222 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Bro, you quoted the Nokkers giving Fushi that info, so basically you believe the Nokkers in being truthful about MiB creating the universe.

You do realize that the Mib is literally present in the scene and confirming everything the nokkers said right? Like it's one thing to suggest the nokkers are lying to Fushi, but it doesnt make any sense for MiB to confirm this information.

Because that wouldn't have made much sense if he could always just 'snap his fingers' and disappear all the Nokkers at anytime he wanted.

I mean he literally explains why he can't do this in season 3. He decided to become human, he gave Fushi his reconnection powers so he can't even locate Nokkers anymore unless they're near him, and that he's losing his powers. By the time his body turns 15 he will be an ordinary human.

Most likely his desire to become a human was his goal for creating Fushi all along. He wanted to be human, but didn't want to leave the world unattended so he created Fushi. Then decided not to just do away with the nokker threat and have Fushi take care of them so that Fushi can mature.

He probably does intend for Fushi to have all his powers eventually but at the moment he's clearly able to do stuff that Fushi is either unable or doesn't know how to do. If he created a new body for piroan there's no reason why he shouldn't be able to create a body for himself.

In closing, don't take what other people say in discussion forums so personally some of us enjoy theorycrafting and it's hella joyless to have to read these itemized replies from someone who's obviously got a lot of time and toxic energy to argue with someone about a cool theory they had the positive enough energy to want to share on a reddit sub

When you present a theory on a public forum like reddit or anywhere else the point is that people will respond to said theory and point out why it does or doesn't work. Me replying is not personal. I also don't think pointing out that it a theory doesn't work because of x and y reason that you might have forgotten is toxic at all. If I insulted you that would be different.

As I said before I didn't even remember a lot of this until I went back and rewatched the series. I remembered Mib saying that Fushi was to be his replacement but completely forgot the revelation that Mib created humanity until I rewatched it. There's nothing wrong with someone pointing out why a theory is wrong as long as they're not rude about it and don't provide spoilers. I don't think I was being rude and I apologize if you felt offended, but if you're really just bothered by people pointing out that your theory has holes in it then there's no real point in posting your theories in the first place. Just keep it to yourself, these threads literally exist to generate conversations. If I made a theory and you told me it was wrong because I forgot some details I wouldn't care at all.

→ More replies (0)